James E. Pepper and Lexington’s distillery district
James E. Pepper inherited his family's distillery as a minor, lost the Woodford County plant after E.H. Taylor Jr.'s bankruptcy, and started over in Lexington with a partner, per historian Michael Veach. ExploreKYHistory says his company took over a distillery site on what is now Manchester Street in 1879 and built six warehouses between 1880 and 1901. Pepper advertised hard, with slogans such as "Born with the Republic" and "Old 1776," and put a strip stamp with his signature over each cork, warning buyers off bottles without it, Veach says. Pepper died in 1906. Just before repeal the company sold out to Schenley, and a 1934 fire destroyed several buildings that were quickly rebuilt, ExploreKYHistory says. In 2008 Amir Peay acquired the abandoned trademark, per Veach, and in December 2017 the rebuilt distillery began distilling again, the company says. Veach says a second distillery, Barrel House, also works on the old Pepper site.
First published Nov 8, 2026, sources last checked Nov 8, 2026.
Where sources disagree
How old is the Pepper brand?
“The Pepper family brand of whiskey is an iconic Kentucky whiskey brand initially produced during the American Revolution and continued through 1967.”
“He came up with the slogans “Born with the Republic” and “Old 1776” in print advertisements, stretching the truth by about three decades, but that was not uncommon at the time.”
When did the old Lexington distillery stop making whiskey?
“Whiskey continued to be made on the site until 1962.”
“In December 2017, the distillery once again began distilling whiskey using the same historic recipe as when it shut down in 1967.”
Key dates
- 1879: The James E. Pepper Distillery takes over the Manchester Street site (per ExploreKYHistory)
- 1880: The James E. Pepper brand is trademarked (per Michael Veach)
- 1906: Pepper dies (per Michael Veach)
- 1934: A fire destroys several buildings (per ExploreKYHistory)
- 1962: Whiskey-making on the site ends (per ExploreKYHistory)
- 2008: Amir Peay acquires the abandoned trademark (per Michael Veach)
- December 2017: The rebuilt distillery begins distilling (James E. Pepper says)
In their words
“In fact, there are presently two distilleries on the site, the new James E. Pepper brand Distillery, as well as, the Barrel House Distillery.”
See it today
- James E. Pepper Distillery
Lexington. Tuesday to Sunday
- Barrel House Distilling Co.
Lexington. Open 7 days a week
Sources
- Michael Veach, Brand History: James E. Pepper . Checked Nov 8, 2026.
- ExploreKYHistory, Lexington Historic Distillery District (on historical marker #2313) . Checked Nov 8, 2026.
- Michael Veach, Lexington Kentucky Distilleries: James E. Pepper . Checked Nov 8, 2026.
- James E. Pepper, home page . Checked Nov 8, 2026.
Bourbon Daybook isn’t affiliated with any distillery or brand named here. See all bourbon stories and how we source stories.