Old Fitzgerald and the John E. Fitzgerald story
Old Fitzgerald dates to 1870, when S.C. Herbst, a Milwaukee rectifier, registered the trademark "Jno. E. Fitzgerald", per historian Michael Veach. The popular story says Fitzgerald worked in Herbst's warehouses and helped himself to the best barrels. Veach says the stories of how the brand was named are mostly marketing: he found a government gauger named John Fitzgerald in Milwaukee, but no evidence he worked for Herbst. Herbst bought Kentucky whiskey and preferred pot-stilled barrels for the brand. During Prohibition he sold it and its stocks to Julian P. Van Winkle, and after repeal it became Stitzel-Weller's flagship, Veach says. Heaven Hill acquired it in 1999 with the Bernheim Distillery, per Heaven Hill's timeline.
First published Nov 8, 2026, sources last checked Nov 8, 2026.
Key dates
- 1870: Herbst registers the trademark (per Michael Veach)
- 1972: Stitzel-Weller is sold and renamed the Old Fitzgerald Distillery (per Michael Veach)
- 1999: Heaven Hill acquires Old Fitzgerald with Bernheim (Heaven Hill says)
In their words
“There are many stories told as to how he created the brand but they are mostly based upon marketing stories.”
See it today
- Stitzel-Weller Distillery
Louisville. Closed Tuesdays
- Heaven Hill Bourbon Experience
Bardstown. Open 7 days a week
Release records: Elijah Craig Barrel Proof, Heaven Hill Grain to Glass, Heaven Hill Heritage Collection, Larceny Barrel Proof, Old Fitzgerald Bottled-in-Bond, Parker's Heritage Collection
Releases at these distilleries
Heaven Hill
- The Bardstown Collection 2026 release party
Thu, Nov 19, 2026
We haven't re-checked this since Nov 8, 2026. Confirm on The Bardstown Collection.At Bardstown Bourbon Co., Heaven Hill, Limestone Branch, Lux Row, Preservation, with Barton 1792. Bardstown, KY
Sold only in person. Price not posted.
Participating distilleries, tastings and a first look at the 2026 Collection. The Collection's site links to tickets and doesn't post the party's exact place or time. Each distillery then sells its own bottle in its own window: Bardstown Bourbon Co., Limestone Branch and Preservation on Friday, Nov 20; Barton 1792, Lux Row and Heaven Hill on Saturday, Nov 21.
Source: The Bardstown Collection ; also Kentucky Distillers' Association event page , checked Nov 8, 2026
- The Bardstown Collection 2026 release at Heaven Hill
Sat, Nov 21, 2026, 5 to 7:30 p.m.
We haven't re-checked this since Nov 8, 2026. Confirm on The Bardstown Collection.Sold only in person. Price not posted.
“Each of the participating distilleries have hand-selected a special expression available only on-site, and only as part of the Bardstown Collection.”
Heaven Hill sells its own Collection bottle in this window. The other Collection windows: Friday, Nov 20: Bardstown Bourbon Co. 9 to 11:30 a.m., Limestone Branch 1 to 3:30 p.m. and Preservation 5 to 7:30 p.m.; Saturday, Nov 21: Barton 1792 9 to 11:30 a.m. and Lux Row 1 to 3:30 p.m. No price is posted.
Source: The Bardstown Collection ; also Kentucky Distillers' Association event page , checked Nov 8, 2026
More stories from these places
- Was Elijah Craig the father of bourbon?
The brand named for a Georgetown preacher calls him the Father of Bourbon. A historian says the credit came almost a century later.
- Isaac W. Bernheim and I.W. Harper
A German immigrant who started out as a peddler built a Louisville whiskey firm and named its flagship for himself and a racehorse owner.
- How whiskey stayed legal in Prohibition: medicinal whiskey
How a few Kentucky companies kept selling whiskey legally, as medicine, while Prohibition shut the rest.
Sources
- Michael Veach, Brand History: Old Fitzgerald . Checked Nov 8, 2026.
- Heaven Hill, Through the Years . Checked Nov 8, 2026.
Bourbon Daybook isn’t affiliated with any distillery or brand named here. See all bourbon stories and how we source stories.