Old Joe and the Old Prentice Distillery
Old Joe whiskey was first made in 1818 by "Old Joe" Peyton on Gilbert's Creek in Anderson County, according to the National Register of Historic Places nomination for the Old Prentice Distillery, prepared by the Kentucky Heritage Council and received in February 1987. The brand passed to the Granville Hawkins family and later through Medley Bond, T. B. Ripy and Wiley Searcy before coming back to a Hawkins descendant. The nomination says the Hawkins firm put up a new plant on Bonds Mill Road in 1912, designed by Frankfort architect Leo Oberwarth in the Spanish Mission style, closed it in 1917 and reopened it after Prohibition to make Old Joe, and that National Distillers bought it in 1941. Historian Michael Veach tells it differently: J.T.S. Brown & Sons bought the distillery in 1894 and renamed it Old Prentice, Creel Brown rebuilt it in the Spanish Mission style in 1910, and after Prohibition it passed briefly to Julius Kessler Distilling before Seagram bought it in 1942. Veach says the Old Prentice Distillery is today's Four Roses Distillery.
First published Nov 8, 2026, sources last checked Nov 8, 2026.
Where sources disagree
Who built the Spanish Mission plant on Bonds Mill Road?
“In 1912 the Hawkins firm erected a new facility at the Montrose Estate on Bond's Mill Road which they called the Old Prentice Distillery.”
“In 1910, J.T.S. Brown’s son, Creel Brown, who was fond of the Spanish Mission style of architecture, decided to rebuild the distillery buildings in this style.”
Who owned it after Prohibition?
“The property was sold to National Distillers Products Company in 1941”
“After Prohibition it was owned briefly by Julius Kessler Distilling Company before being purchased by Joseph E. Seagrams & Sons in 1942.”
Key dates
- 1818: "Old Joe" Peyton makes Old Joe whiskey (per National Park Service)
- 1894: J.T.S. Brown & Sons buys the distillery and renames it Old Prentice (per Michael Veach)
- 1910: Creel Brown rebuilds it in the Spanish Mission style (per Michael Veach)
- 1912: The Hawkins firm builds the Old Prentice Distillery (per National Park Service)
- 1917: The distillery closes (per National Park Service)
- 1933: Reopened after Prohibition, making Old Joe (per National Park Service)
- 1941: National Distillers buys it (per National Park Service)
- 1942: Seagram buys it (per Michael Veach)
In their words
“The Old Prentice Distillery is the best example of Spanish Mission architecture in Kentucky.”
“Old Joe Whiskey was first produced in 1818 by "Old Joe" Peyton on Gilbert's Creek in Anderson County.”
“At the height of Seagram’s expansion into the Bourbon World they owned five distilleries in Kentucky”
“The Old Prentice Distillery is the present day Four Roses Distillery in Lawrenceburg, Kentucky.”
See it today
- Four Roses Distillery
Lawrenceburg. Wednesday to Sunday
Release records: Four Roses Limited Edition Small Batch
Releases at these distilleries
Four Roses
- Limited Edition Small Batch 2026
Went on sale Sat, Oct 10, 2026
Also sold outside the distillery; the source says where. $249 (suggested retail).
About 16,800 bottles at 109.2 proof. Also sold at retailers nationwide.
Source: Four Roses news release , checked Nov 8, 2026
- Experimental Series No. 002 Honey Cask Finish
Went on sale Fri, Sep 18, 2026
At Four Roses and Four Roses Warehouse & Bottling
Sold only in person. $55 plus applicable tax (suggested retail, 375 ml).
Sold only at the two Four Roses visitor centers, Lawrenceburg and Cox's Creek.
Source: Four Roses news release (Aug 25, 2026) , checked Nov 8, 2026
More stories from these places
- Four Roses: the corsage story and the years away
A brand that says it began with a proposal and a corsage, and that came back to US shelves after 2002.
- How whiskey stayed legal in Prohibition: medicinal whiskey
How a few Kentucky companies kept selling whiskey legally, as medicine, while Prohibition shut the rest.
Sources
- National Register of Historic Places nomination, Old Prentice Distillery, Anderson County (Kentucky Heritage Council, 1986-87) . Checked Nov 8, 2026.
- Michael Veach, Kentucky's Great Distilleries: Four Roses, Masters of Yeast . Checked Nov 8, 2026.
- Michael Veach, Images of the Past: Old Prentice Distillery . Checked Nov 8, 2026.
Bourbon Daybook isn’t affiliated with any distillery or brand named here. See all bourbon stories and how we source stories.