Old Taylor Distillery, the castle on Glenns Creek
Historian Michael Veach says E.H. Taylor Jr. saw beer tourism in Germany and decided bourbon needed something like it. Taylor fashioned his Frankfort distillery as a castle and added a sunken garden and a pergola over the springs, Veach says. Castle & Key, which occupies the site now, says Taylor built a springhouse in the shape of a key. The two disagree on the start date: Castle & Key gives 1887 as the year Taylor founded the Old Taylor Distillery, and Veach says Taylor and his sons took charge of the distillery in 1884 and renamed it. Taylor died in 1923, per Veach. Castle & Key says Will Arvin and a small group found the abandoned distillery in 2012 and reopened it in 2016.
First published Nov 8, 2026, sources last checked Nov 8, 2026.
Where sources disagree
- When did it become the Old Taylor Distillery?
The summary above gives each side and who says it.
Key dates
- 1884: Taylor and his sons rename it the Old Taylor Distillery (per Michael Veach)
- 1887: The year Castle & Key gives for its founding (Castle & Key says)
- 1923: Taylor dies (per Michael Veach)
- 2012: Castle & Key's founders find the abandoned site (Castle & Key says)
- 2016: Reopens as Castle & Key (Castle & Key says)
In their words
“In 1884 he and his sons took charge of the distillery and re-named it”
What we haven’t found a source for
- We haven't found a source that gives the year the Old Taylor Distillery closed.
See it today
- Castle & Key Distillery
Frankfort. Wednesday to Sunday
More stories from these places
- Old Grand-Dad and Basil Hayden’s face
Basil Hayden's smiling face went on Old Grand-Dad bottles in the 1890s. A historian traced how that face changed over the next century.
- Who invented bourbon tourism?
Maker's Mark credits Margie Samuels. Castle & Key says it began at E.H. Taylor's Old Taylor Distillery.
- “What is whiskey?” E.H. Taylor Jr. and the Taft Decision
After the 1906 food and drug law, E.H. Taylor Jr. argued that only bonded straight whiskey deserved the name, Veach says. President Taft ruled in 1909.
Sources
- Castle & Key, The History of Castle & Key . Checked Nov 8, 2026.
- Michael Veach, Bourbon Barons: Edmund Haynes Taylor Jr. . Checked Nov 8, 2026.
Bourbon Daybook isn’t affiliated with any distillery or brand named here. See all bourbon stories and how we source stories.