“What is whiskey?” E.H. Taylor Jr. and the Taft Decision
E.H. Taylor Jr., the Frankfort distiller who started the OFC distillery in the 1870s and later founded the Old Taylor Distillery, firmly supported the Bottled-in-Bond Act of 1897, per historian Michael Veach. Once the Pure Food and Drug Act passed in June 1906, the question became what could be called whiskey. Taylor argued that only bottled-in-bond whiskey was whiskey and that everything else be labeled imitation whiskey, in line with a ruling by government chemist Harvey Washington Wiley, Veach says. Taylor wrote for newspapers and trade papers and testified before President Taft. Taft's decision of December 27, 1909, let rectified whiskey be called whiskey if it was labeled blended whiskey, so Taylor was only partly successful, Veach says, though straight whiskey gained a legal definition and bottled-in-bond became the standard for quality.
First published Nov 8, 2026, sources last checked Nov 8, 2026.
Key dates
All three per Michael Veach.
- 1897: The Bottled-in-Bond Act, which Taylor supported
- June 1906: The Pure Food and Drug Act passes
- December 27, 1909: President Taft releases his decision on whiskey
In their words
“Taylor put forward the belief that only whiskey that was bottled-in-bond was whiskey and everything else should be labeled imitation whiskey.”
“In the end, he was only partly successful as the Taft Decision allows rectified whiskey to be called whiskey, but only if it is labeled as a “blended whiskey”.”
See it today
- Buffalo Trace Distillery
Frankfort. Open 7 days a week
Release records: Buffalo Trace Antique Collection, E.H. Taylor limited releases, Elmer T. Lee commemoratives, Pappy Van Winkle, Weller limited releases
- Castle & Key Distillery
Frankfort. Wednesday to Sunday
Releases at these distilleries
Buffalo Trace
- Bottle Draw: Elmer T. Lee 40th Anniversary Bourbon
Entry closed Sep 17, 2026; pickup ran Sep 28 to Oct 11
Sold only in person. $99.99 plus sales tax (posted price, 750 ml).
One entry per person. Up to 5,000 winners were picked at random, and each could buy one bottle in person at the distillery.
Source: Buffalo Trace Bottle Draw official rules , checked Nov 8, 2026
More stories from these places
- O.F.C. and the George T. Stagg Distillery
Before it was Buffalo Trace, the Frankfort distillery was E.H. Taylor's O.F.C. and then George T. Stagg's.
- Old Grand-Dad and Basil Hayden’s face
Basil Hayden's smiling face went on Old Grand-Dad bottles in the 1890s. A historian traced how that face changed over the next century.
- Old Taylor Distillery, the castle on Glenns Creek
E.H. Taylor Jr. built a castle of a distillery to draw visitors. It stood empty for decades and opened again as Castle & Key.
Sources
- Michael Veach, E.H. Taylor Jr. and Bottled-in-Bond Whiskey . Checked Nov 8, 2026.
- Michael Veach, Edmond Haynes Taylor and James Edward Pepper . Checked Nov 8, 2026.
Bourbon Daybook isn’t affiliated with any distillery or brand named here. See all bourbon stories and how we source stories.