Pappygate: the Buffalo Trace and Wild Turkey thefts
WhiskyCast put the 2013 loss from a Buffalo Trace warehouse in Frankfort at about 65 cases of Pappy, and said the cases left behind had been rearranged on pallets to hide the gap. NPR's 2015 story gave a different count: more than 200 bottles of Pappy that had been aging in a locked area of the distillery. Gilbert "Toby" Curtsinger, who worked as a warehouse supervisor, was the admitted ringleader of thefts from Wild Turkey and Buffalo Trace, per WhiskyCast, which counts him among ten people indicted in 2015; NPR reported in April 2015 that Sheriff Melton had announced nine indictments. He pleaded guilty, and in June 2018 the Franklin County Circuit Court sentenced him to 15 years. Later that month Judge Thomas Wingate granted him shock probation, after about 30 days in jail, per The State Journal.
First published Nov 8, 2026, sources last checked Nov 8, 2026.
Where sources disagree
- How much Van Winkle went missing in 2013?
- How many people were indicted?
The summary above gives each side and who says it.
Key dates
- 2013: Cases of Pappy go missing from Buffalo Trace (per WhiskyCast)
- 2015: Ten people are indicted (per WhiskyCast)
- April 21, 2015: NPR reports Sheriff Melton's announcement of nine indictments (per NPR)
- June 2018: Curtsinger is sentenced to 15 years (per WhiskyCast)
- June 29, 2018: Curtsinger is granted shock probation (per The State Journal)
What we haven’t found a source for
- We haven't found a source for what finally happened to the seized whiskey; in June 2018 WhiskyCast said the judge had yet to decide.
See it today
- Buffalo Trace Distillery
Frankfort. Open 7 days a week
Release records: Buffalo Trace Antique Collection, E.H. Taylor limited releases, Elmer T. Lee commemoratives, Pappy Van Winkle, Weller limited releases
- Wild Turkey Distillery
Lawrenceburg. Wednesday to Sunday
Release records: Russell's Reserve 13, Wild Turkey Master's Keep
Releases at these distilleries
Buffalo Trace
- Bottle Draw: Elmer T. Lee 40th Anniversary Bourbon
Entry closed Sep 17, 2026; pickup ran Sep 28 to Oct 11
Sold only in person. $99.99 plus sales tax (posted price, 750 ml).
One entry per person. Up to 5,000 winners were picked at random, and each could buy one bottle in person at the distillery.
Source: Buffalo Trace Bottle Draw official rules , checked Nov 8, 2026
More stories from these places
- Wild Turkey Hill and the Ripy brothers
The Ripy family's Lawrenceburg distillery, and how a hunting trip gave the bourbon its name, as Wild Turkey tells it.
- O.F.C. and the George T. Stagg Distillery
Before it was Buffalo Trace, the Frankfort distillery was E.H. Taylor's O.F.C. and then George T. Stagg's.
- “What is whiskey?” E.H. Taylor Jr. and the Taft Decision
After the 1906 food and drug law, E.H. Taylor Jr. argued that only bonded straight whiskey deserved the name, Veach says. President Taft ruled in 1909.
Sources
- WhiskyCast, "PappyGate" Ringleader Sentenced to 15 Years (June 2, 2018) . Checked Nov 8, 2026.
- The State Journal, Curtsinger granted shock probation in 'Pappygate' case (June 29, 2018) . Checked Nov 8, 2026.
- NPR's story "At Last: Kentucky Authorities Bust Ring Behind Great Bourbon Heist" (All Things Considered, April 21, 2015), as published by WNYC . Checked Nov 8, 2026.
Bourbon Daybook isn’t affiliated with any distillery or brand named here. See all bourbon stories and how we source stories.